So you came across my post on numberless word problems, you got excited by the idea, but you’re left wondering, “Where does he get the problems from?” Good question! I thought it was high time I answer it.

For starters, I try to avoid writing problems from scratch whenever possible. I can do it, and I have done it on numerous occasions, but I’ll be honest, it’s mentally exhausting if you have to write more than one or two problems in one sitting! It takes a lot of work to think of context after context for a variety of math topics, especially if you don’t want to feel like you’re reusing the same context over and over again.

I’ll let you in on a secret. More often than not, I base my questions on existing questions out in the world. I don’t reuse them wholesale, partly because I don’t want to infringe on copyright and partly because I don’t want to deprive teachers in my district of an existing problem they could be using with their students.

I always change names and numbers, and as needed I tweak the contexts and questions. This is so much easier than writing problems from scratch! Basing my problems on existing problems makes me feel like I’m starting 10-20 steps ahead of where I would have otherwise!

I’ll share a few problems I’ve created to give you an idea of what I’m talking about. I based all three of them off grade 3 2015 STAAR sample questions released by the Texas Education Agency.

## Problem 1

Here’s the original problem:

First, I thought about how I could adjust the problem to make it my own:

- I decided to change the character to Jenise.
- I changed “flowers” to “carrot plants.”
- I changed 21 to 24. I did this intentionally because 24 has so many factors. You’ll see how this plays out when you get to the sample questions I created later.
- I removed the number 3 altogether. Again, this plays out later when I created questions about the situation.

Note: This step is only necessary if you want to create a unique problem. The released tests are free to be used, so you could just as easily convert this exact problem into a numberless word problem. Again, I don’t want to steal resources from my teachers so I’m opting to change this into a new problem.

Next, I think about how I want to scaffold presenting the information in the problem. I create slides, one for each phase of revealing information. Remember, the purpose of a numberless word problem is to give students an opportunity to collaboratively identify and make sense of mathematical relationships in a situation *before* being presented with a question. There are several factors that dictate how much or how little new information to present on each slide:

- Students’ attention span
- Students’ familiarity with the type of situation being presented
- Students’ familiarity with the math concepts involved in the situation

Here’s how I broke down this question into 4 slides:

Slide 1

Slide 2

Slide 3

Slide 4

Thinking this would be used in a 3rd grade classroom, I opted to break it down quite a bit to draw emphasis on the language of “rows” and “same number in each row.” If I already knew my students were comfortable connecting this language to multiplication and division, then I probably would have combined slides 2 and 3 into one slide.

At this point, I stop and think about what question I want to ask about the full situation on slide 4. If I were a teacher, I might select a question and keep it in my pocket. After discussing slide 4, I’d ask my students what questions they think could be asked about this situation. Students need opportunities to generate problems for themselves, not just be told the problems we expect them to solve. I could allow them to answer their own question before answering the one I had planned (or instead of!).

Here are a few questions I generated that I might ask about this situation:

This is where changing 21 to 24 in the problem adds some richness to the potential questions I could ask about this situation. This is also the reason I removed the number 3 from the original problem. Not specifying the number of rows allowed me more flexibility to ask about either the number of rows or the number of plants in each row.

## Problem 2

Here’s the original problem:

I like this problem, so I didn’t want to change it too much. Here are the changes I decided to make. Remember, I always change names and numbers; context and question are tweaked as necessary.

- I changed the character to Mrs. Prentice.
- I changed the food from “yoghurt cups” to “pints of ice cream.”
- I changed the flavors to chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla.
- I changed all three numbers. However, I noted that there was a way to make ten (6 + 4) in the ones, tens, and hundreds places across the 3 numbers, so I tried to create a similar structure in my numbers with 3 + 7.

With those changes, here’s how I scaffolded the problem across 5 slides:

Slide 1

Slide 2

Slide 3

Slide 4

Slide 5

Depending on my students, I might have combined slides 4 and 5. Keeping them separate means I can play it safe. I can reveal each number one at a time, but I can also breeze through slides 3 and 4 if the situation warrants it and spend more time talking about all three numbers on slide 5.

And finally, it’s time to think of some potential questions that can be asked about this situation:

By the way, this is a great time to point out that I don’t have to pick just one! I spent valuable time crafting the situation and my students will spend valuable time making sense of the situation. Milk it for all it’s worth!

I could pose one question today for students to solve and discuss. Tomorrow we could revisit the same situation, maybe just talking about slide 5 together to jog our memories, and then I could give them another question to solve about this situation. I could even pose 2-3 questions and let the students *choose* which one they want to solve. Be creative!

## Problem 3

Here’s the original problem:

I like this one because I’m able to take a 3rd grade problem and make it fit concepts for grades 3-5. In this case, I didn’t change as much of the original problem because the context is so simple. Here are the 3 slides I created to scaffold presenting the information:

Slide 1

Slide 2

Slide 3

It’s important to remember that the power of a numberless word problem lies in the *conversation* students have as you reveal each new piece of information. That conversation is driven by the questions you ask as more and more information is revealed. Here are sample questions you could use as you discuss each slide of a numberless word problem:

- What do you know?
- What information have you been given?
- What do you understand about the information given?
- What kind of problem could this be?
- What information do you know now?
- Does this new information help you?
- What does the new information tell you?
- How does the new information change or support your thinking?
- What operation(s) does this situation make you think about?
- What kinds of questions could be asked about this situation? (This can be asked on several slides, not just the final one.)

The fun part for this particular situation was thinking of all the different questions I could ask:

So there you have it – three very different examples of numberless word problems. As cool as I think numberless word problems are, please note that not every problem needs to be a numberless word problem. We have to be intentional about when and how much we provide scaffolding to our students. However, knowing about this type of problem is a great tool to have in your belt when you’re looking for ways to help your students develop a deeper understanding of the mathematical relationships in real life situations.

If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to ask in the comments!

[*UPDATE – I’ve made a page on my blog devoted to numberless word problems. Check it out for more resources.*]

Pingback: Numberless Word Problems | Teaching to the Beat of a Different Drummer

howardat58The problem with “word problems” is that students rapidly come to see them as buried arithmetic problems, whereas in fact most are two problems in one: “What do I need to do to the numbers?” followed by “How do I do the sums?” The first is the application of math to the “real” world and the second is arithmetic. So if we are trying to teach math more attention should be given to the first, whose answer is a set of instructions on what to do with the quantities involved, which can be in ordinary language or as a formula (algebra!). This aspect can be pursued without any need to do “sums” except as a means of seeing if the “formula” gives sensible answers to simple sets of numbers. If you don’t know this book, written many many years ago, have a look:

Click to access problemswithoutfigures.pdf

ps. Your first one uses carrots. Unless they do it differently in the USA you sow the carrot seeds and when you have a row of little plants you thin them out. No planting carrot plants. You could try leeks instead, or tomato plants.

bstockusPost authorI completely agree. It’s the issue of students viewing them as “buried arithmetic problems” that led my co-worker to come up with numberless word problems in our district. The goal is much less about finding the answer than it is making sense of the situation and determining what operation(s) could be used to answer the question that is finally presented. If students can get to the point of doing the correct calculation, then this routine/structure has succeeded. Actually performing any calculations correctly is another can of worms entirely.

Thank you for sharing the book! I have seen it here and there, but I haven’t spent much time going through it. I’ll be sure to take a closer look.

And thanks for the comment about the carrots. Calling them carrot seeds makes more sense. I’ll find some time later and update the post.

goldenojNice teaching think aloud! It’s perfect for sharing with my preservice elementary teachers.

Sometimes I like even leaving out the questions. “A farmer gives a quarter of a bale of hay to each of his 3 horses every week day. What questions can you ask and answer?”

bstockusPost authorThanks!

I agree about leaving out the question. One of our instructional coaches tends to leave out the question, putting it on the students to come up with one. She’s always impressed at how they always ask more challenging questions that she ever would have, and because they generated them, they’re that much more motivated to solve them!

gfletchyThis is solid Brian! Thanks for fleshing out your ideas for us all to learn and grow. Have you ever thought about creating a bank of numberless word problems for people to submit them? Just saying:-)

bstockusPost authorWell we all know the rabbit hole this comment (and a subsequent email) have led me down…

🙂

Marge Kobewka.Thanks for explaining this so clearly and providing examples. I can see how numberless word problems help students focus on communicating the mathematical relationships they see. It’s helpful to see the way you break down the questions into parts. I like the fact that you use word problems that have already been created and modify them. Really, there’s a wealth of traditional word problems that we can transform. Thanks! I teach grade 3 in Canada and I’ll use these ideas with my students. I’ll contribute to a problem bank.

bstockusPost authorThank you! I’m glad you found the post helpful, and it sounds like you completely got the message I was trying to convey. I agree that reusing (transforming!) existing word problems is a great place to start so we’re not always having to work from scratch and it gives teachers freedom to modify problems in ways that might reflect their students’ identities and interests better.

Debbie BodenLove how you explained in so much detail. I think it’s really helpful for teachers that aren’t sure how to let go of the book! I’m going to share this with my middle school teachers!

bstockusPost authorThank you! I’d love to hear how it goes after you share with your middle school teachers. I definitely think this routine/structure can be used across grade levels!

Pingback: Numberless Word Problems 1 – undercover calculus

Pingback: #MTBoS Life: Ramblings and Musings from an Inspirational NCTM – undercover calculus

mathkaveliBrian, this is truly golden! Loving this idea, I’m creating something with this in mind, may I share it with you?

Susan RyanGreat strategy! Love the idea of altering the problems. I have done that as well. I love the thought process that goes through the problem being broad and the process through having all the information to actually solve.

Kevetta TaylorVery detailed, and helps understand word problem much better!

Melina HarrisI like this strategy, as it is teaching students to think critically. It’s a good one

lindaExample are great

Ashley SkenterisI appreciate the scaffolding approach to introducing each portion of the word problem.

Jeannette TerranovaI do spend time rewriting word problems. It is important to reinforce the correct terms and level of difficulty using examples.

Avery CameronIt’s an awesome way to decompose the building a multi-step word problem. Great way to train our brains to slow down and pick it all apart, bit by bit:)

RoseAnother question they might ask (or something you might have to clarify): is the number of flowers in each row the same? Is the fraction of bales of hay the same each day? It would depend on what you wanted the students to get out of it. Maybe that could be a slide in the middle.

J SlaytonWondering if anyone has had success using numberless word problems in upper grades. I work with teachers K – 12 and have been trying to adapt high school problems to be numberless and it seems to lack something. I’m looking for feedback or advice.

suevanhattumLike J Slayton, I am thinking of using this with older students. I teach at community college. I’ll keep thinking about this.

I have one suggestion. In problem 2 the book used Ms. and you changed that to Mrs. This has to do with equity issues for girls and boys, who will grow up to be men and women. If women’s title (Ms., Mrs., or Miss) is affected by marriage, that has implications which are very different than what exists for men (always Mr.). Ms. was invented by feminists so that women could use a title without referring to their marriage status. I would suggest leaving out titles entirely, or else sticking with the Ms.

Jan BakerThis makes the students concentrate on the words and their concepts before trying to solve the question.